intervention

Home » intervention

Shouldn’t we intervene in other countries if we could save lives?

in Ask Dr. Ruwart, Foreign Policy, Liberator Online by Mary Ruwart Comments are off

Shouldn’t we intervene in other countries if we could save lives?

This article was featured in our weekly newsletter, the Liberator Online. To receive it in your inbox, sign up here.

Question

If we have the power to save lives by intervening internationally, which is the greater evil: imposing our will on others or the destruction of lives? Yes, it is correct that we tend to ignore civil strife in areas where we would either get bloodied or areas we don’t care about (like Rwanda), but should we intervene where we can do so at little physical cost if a net balance of lives can be gained?

lives

Answer

Ah, the age old question, ‘Can the ends justify the means?’ I’ve come to the conclusion that when we use bad means to obtain good ends, our efforts backfire every time. Rather than supporting a war funded with taxes, I chose to help the refugees.

Naturally, when you, as an individual, feel that you can do good by supporting a fight, you should follow your conscience by supplying your own time, money, and effort. If you force your neighbor who feels differently to participate, however, you’ll jeopardize your cause. After all, by using taxes to support the fight, you are first attacking your peaceful neighbors to save others from tyranny. You become the tyrant in order to save others from oppression. The contradiction should be obvious.

Many people applaud our entry into World War II as an example of how good (e.g., defeating Hitler) can come out of bad (e.g., taxes and the draft). With the advantage of historical hindsight, let’s see if this is an accurate description of what happened.

Hitler offered to let the Jews leave Germany if other countries would accept them. Few nations would alter their immigration quotas, however. If you visit the Holocaust Museum in Washington D.C., you can see a picture of a shipload of Jews being turned away from U.S. shores. They eventually had to return to Europe, where most of them were killed. Without the aggression of immigration laws, we could have saved the Jews without spilling the blood of our young men.

Japan’s attack on Pearl Harbor probably wouldn’t have occurred without the aggression of a U.S. oil embargo, saving the lives of our servicemen there.

Hitler’s finest were already trying to assassinate him by the time the U.S. entered the war and probably would have succeeded eventually. Instead, the U.S. entered the war, took Stalin as an ally, and gave Stalin most of Eastern Europe. Stalin proceeded to kill millions, without offering to let them migrate elsewhere, making Hitler look benevolent in comparison. Those who survived these purges were forced to live in constant fear, poverty, and strife. Did our aggression against our own neighbors make war on tyrants save lives or take them? The body count suggests that our aggression cost more lives than it saved.

Obama Administration Spends $500 million to Train Only 60 Syrian Rebels

in Liberator Online by Jackson Jones Comments are off

This article was featured in our weekly newsletter, the Liberator Online. To receive it in your inbox, sign up here.

As the Obama administration tried to convince Congress to support intervention against the dictatorial regime of Syrian President Bashar Assad in the summer of 2013, officials insisted that only a quarter of Syrian rebels had ties to Islamic extremist groups. That turned out to be inaccurate. An estimate produced by IHS Jane’s found that nearly half were Islamic extremists.

Fast-forward to June 2014, when the administration asked Congress for $500 million to train and equip to several thousand so-called “moderate” Syrian rebels to, now, fight the Islamic State, which operates in Syria, as well as Iraq and other Middle Eastern countries. Congress approved the funding request in December.

CNN reports, however, that the only 60 rebels have been vetted to participate in the program. Recruits cannot have any ties to terrorist organizations. “We make sure that they, for example, aren’t going to pose a green-on-blue threat to their trainers; that they don’t have any history of atrocities,” Defense Secretary Ash Carter told the Senate Armed Services Committee of the vetting process on Tuesday.

“I expect that number to improve,” he said, “but you deserve to know the truth.

The plan was to train some 15,000-rebel fighters over three years. Although 7,000 potential recruits are currently being vetted, Carter’s testimony didn’t sit well with members of the committee, including Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., a prominent foreign policy hawk who has criticized the administration for its handling of the Islamic State, as well as not ousting Assad in 2013.

“I’ve got to tell you after four years [since the Syrian Civil War began], Mr. Secretary, that’s not a very impressive number,” McCain told Carter. McCain suggested that U.S.-trained fighters be allowed to target Assad’s forces, whom they aren’t trained to engage.

The numbers may be low because many would-be fighters are more interested in toppling Assad and taking control of Syria than fighting the Islamic State, which is just one extremist group fighting the regime. Others include al-Qaeda and Hamas. Hezbollah and Iran are supporting Assad.

The foreign policy venture in Syria is already proving to be a failure, and yet, it’s amazing that some, like McCain, want to United States to get further involved by allowing fighters to go after Assad’s forces in addition to fighting the Islamic State. It may not be as sordid of an affair as Iraq, but it could be.

If there’s anything our history of intervention has taught us is that we’re not very good at it. Perhaps we would be better served if, for once, we stayed out of the fight.

Reason: Three Reasons Not to Go To War With Syria

in The Feed by Advocates HQ Comments are off

Reason has published a video with 3 simple reasons why we ought not go to war with Syria.

Description: As the Obama administration beats the drum for yet another military engagement, here are three reasons we shouldn’t go to war with Syria.

Kansas City Chiefs Mega Oval Fixed 2 Hitch Cover, wholesale jerseys,Men’s New England Patriots Pro Line Heathered Gray Heritage II Big & Tall T-Shirt, wholesale nfl jerseys, wholesale nfl jerseys from china,Women’s New York Giants Nike Gray New Day Tri-Blend Tank Top.Men’s San Diego Chargers Nike Navy Kick Off Staff Performance Pullover Hoodie, Cheap New Orleans Saints Jerseys,Women’s San Diego Chargers For Bare Feet Highwire Mismatch Leg Warmers,Men’s Cleveland Browns G-III Sports by Carl Banks Brown Touchdown Hoodie.cheap nfl decals year 2000,wholesale jerseys 4u, cheap nfl jerseys,Women’s Houston Texans Majestic Navy/Red Football Miracle T-Shirt.Men’s Buffalo Bills Nike Royal 2015 Sideline Crew Fleece Performance Sweatshirt, wholesale jerseys,Women’s Green Bay Packers Klew Green/Gold Big Logo V-Neck Ugly Sweater, Cheap Jerseys china,Nike Manti Te’o San Diego Chargers Youth Game Jersey wholesale nfl jerseys.Men’s New England Patriots John Hannah Nike Navy Blue Retired Player Game Jersey, wholesale jerseys from china,Women’s Denver Broncos Love Glitter Slide Slippers Cheap Jerseys china.wholesale nfl leather jackets,cheap nfl tickets xl,Tampa Bay Buccaneers Tervis Tumbler 24oz. Gridiron Wrap Tumbler.Youth Kansas City Chiefs Red 3-Pack T-Shirt Set,Women’s Pittsburgh Steelers Concepts Sport Black Fusion T-Shirt,Mens Cutter & Buck Royal Blue New York Giants DryTec Edge Quarter Zip Pullover Jacket.Men’s New York Giants Nike Royal Game Day Half-Zip Knit Performance Tri-Blend Jacket,Kansas City Chiefs Black Steering Wheel Cover,Men’s Houston Texans New Era Navy Blue/Red 2015 NFL Draft 39THIRTY Flex Hat

Should the US intervene in Syria?

in The Feed by Advocates HQ Comments are off

This is the one year anniversary of the Obama “red line” comments in which the President stated that the military should intervene if Assad used chemical weapons. Sadly, it is clear that the Syrian government did. Now the President now has a choice: intervene in Syria or let his words ring hollow.

’47 Brand Kansas City Chiefs Cleanup Wordmark Adjustable Hat – Red, cheap jerseys,New York Jets 11.5″ x 17″ Helmet Ultra Decal Window Cling, wholesale jerseys from china,Women’s Chicago Bears Majestic Charcoal On The Fifty Meant To Win T-Shirt.Super Bowl XLVIII Beach Towel, Cheap Jerseys free shipping,Men’s Carolina Panthers ’47 Black Chopblock Cuffed Knit Hat, Cheap Jerseys from china,Mens San Diego Chargers Nike Gray Retro Logo T-Shirt.Women’s Tampa Bay Buccaneers Nike Pewter Logo Wrap Tri-Blend V-Neck Long Sleeve T-Shirt, Cheap Jerseys from china,Men’s Baltimore Ravens New Era Gray/Graphite Gold Collection 39THIRTY Flex Hat.Men’s Jacksonville Jaguars Nike Black 2015 Sideline Crew Fleece Performance Sweatshirt,Green Bay Packers Riddell Gold Mini Speed Helmet.Infant San Diego Chargers ’47 Navy Little Monster Knit Beanie, wholesale jerseys, Cheap Jerseys free shipping,Houston Texans iPhone 6 Slim Phone Case,Men’s Oakland Raiders Majestic Black Past the Limit Marled T-Shirt wholesale nfl jerseys.Men’s New Orleans Saints Nike Black Stadium Touch Performance T-Shirt, wholesale nfl jerseys from china,Tampa Bay Buccaneers 2015 Game Coin.Men’s New England Patriots G-III Sports by Carl Banks Navy Instant Replay Micro-Fleece Jacket,Womens Jacksonville Jaguars Touch by Alyssa Milano Black Morgan T-Shirt cheap jerseys.Tennessee Titans 23″ Mission Tiffany Table Lamp,Men’s Dallas Cowboys Mitchell & Ness Black On the Fifty Crew Neck Sweatshirt,Men’s Philadelphia Eagles Green Wordmark Rugby Polo

In a video post on June 8, 2013, Doug Bandow explains why intervention is the wrong approach for Americans and Syrians.

Video Description:

Doug Bandow is a senior fellow at the Cato Institute, specializing in foreign policy and civil liberties. He worked as special assistant to President Reagan and editor of the political magazine Inquiry. He writes regularly for leading publications such as Fortune magazine, National Interest, Wall Street Journal, and Washington Times. Bandow speaks frequently at academic conferences, on college campuses, and to business groups. Bandow has been a regular commentator on ABC, CBS, NBC, CNN, Fox News Channel, and MSNBC. He holds a J.D. from Stanford University. Video produced by Caleb O. Brown and Austin Bragg.