What are the differences between Libertarians and Conservatives?
Differences between libertarians and conservatives usually come down to issues of personal freedom. Libertarians generally think that individual behaviors should be permitted so long as they harm no other person. Conservatives think that, even though certain behaviors may bring no direct harm to others, said behaviors must be curtailed or forbidden to prevent social decay and decline, not to mention negative secondary effects on society. For example, a libertarian might agree that illicit drug use should be permitted. In contrast, a conservative is likely to think that allowing such behavior risks people destroying their lives with addiction. Whereas libertarians tend to trust individuals to be personally responsible and bear the costs/consequences of their actions, conservatives worry that secondary social costs of such behaviors will invariably be too high. Libertarians are quick to reply that prohibition and the brutal prosecution of the Drug War have created enormous social problems of their own.
How are Libertarians and Conservatives similar?
Libertarians and conservatives tend to agree that entrepreneurship is the primary mechanism for generating prosperity. Both types think people should be free to engage in entrepreneurial activity and keep rewards of entrepreneurial value creation. Both libertarians and conservatives, therefore, support low taxes and limited government.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Dimension | Libertarian | Conservative |
|---|---|---|
| Role of Government | Minimize coercive power; force legitimate only in defense of individual rights | Moderate: defend order, tradition, and national interests |
| Economic Policy | Free markets, low or no taxes, minimal regulation | Free markets, low taxes, increasingly open to tariffs and industrial policy |
| Personal Freedom | Maximum: oppose all victimless crime laws | Selective: restrict behaviors seen as threatening to traditional values |
| Drug Policy | Legalize and regulate | Mostly prohibitionist |
| Foreign Policy | Non-interventionist | Strong military, willing to project power abroad |
| Immigration | Generally favor liberalized immigration | Generally favor restrictions |
| Gun Rights | Strongly pro-gun | Strongly pro-gun |
| Role of Religion in Public Life | Strict neutrality: no state endorsement of religion | Often supportive of religious expression in public institutions |
| Attitude Toward Tradition | Skeptical: tradition isn't automatically wise | Reverent: inherited institutions embody accumulated wisdom |
| Core Philosophical Foundation | Individual rights and non-aggression | Virtue, order, and social cohesion |
Key Figures
Prominent Libertarian Thinkers
Prominent libertarian thinkers and leaders include Murray Rothbard (1926-1995), the economist and philosopher often called "Mr. Libertarian," who synthesized Austrian economics with natural rights philosophy; Ron Paul (1935-), the former Congressman whose presidential campaigns introduced millions to libertarian ideas; F.A. Hayek (1899-1992), the Austrian economist whose The Road to Serfdom and The Constitution of Liberty remain foundational texts; Milton Friedman (1912-2006), the Nobel Prize-winning economist who championed free markets to a popular audience and is claimed by both camps; and Ayn Rand (1905-1982), the novelist and philosopher whose Atlas Shrugged and The Fountainhead influenced generations of libertarians. For more, see our full treatment of libertarian thought and history.
Prominent Conservative Thinkers
Prominent conservative thinkers and leaders include Edmund Burke (1729-1797), the Anglo-Irish statesman and founder of modern conservative thought; Russell Kirk (1918-1994), author of The Conservative Mind (1953), which traced the intellectual lineage of American conservatism; William F. Buckley Jr. (1925-2008), founder of National Review and the key figure in postwar American conservatism; Ronald Reagan (1911-2004), the 40th President and the defining political figure of modern conservatism; and Thomas Sowell (1930-), the economist and public intellectual whose libertarian-conservative synthesis has shaped conservative thinking on race, culture, and economics. For more, see our full treatment of conservative thought and history.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can someone be both libertarian and conservative?
Many people hold views that blend elements of both. The term "fusionism," coined by Frank Meyer in the 1950s, describes the attempt to unite the two positions into a coherent political philosophy. Libertarian-leaning conservatives like Ron Paul, Rand Paul, and Thomas Massie operate within the Republican Party while holding many libertarian positions. However, fusionism has always had its critics on both sides, and the rise of national conservatism in recent years has strained the alliance considerably.
Do libertarians vote Republican?
Many do, especially in federal elections where a third-party vote feels futile. Others vote for Libertarian Party candidates, and some do not vote at all on philosophical grounds. The Libertarian Party is the third-largest political party in the United States. There is no single libertarian voting strategy, and libertarians divide on whether working within major-party politics is more effective than building an alternative.
Which is more "right-wing," libertarian or conservative?
The traditional left-right spectrum does not map cleanly onto libertarianism. On economic policy, libertarians and conservatives are both on the "right": they both support free markets and low taxes. On personal freedom issues like drug policy, immigration, and civil liberties, libertarians hold positions that would be considered "left" by most Americans. This is why the Nolan Chart, which maps political views on two axes rather than one, better captures where libertarians actually stand. On the Nolan Chart, libertarians appear at the top (high on both economic and personal freedom) while conservatives appear to the upper right (high on economic freedom, lower on personal freedom).
Are libertarians socially liberal?
In the sense that libertarians oppose laws restricting consensual private behavior, yes. But libertarians reach this conclusion on different grounds than progressives do. Progressives often see personal freedom as a positive good that government should actively promote. Libertarians see personal freedom as a consequence of individual rights that no one has legitimate authority to violate, whether that "no one" is a government, a majority, or another private individual. A libertarian might personally disapprove of a particular lifestyle while still defending the legal right to pursue it.
What happened to the Reagan-era alliance between libertarians and conservatives?
The postwar alliance between the two movements, often associated with figures like William F. Buckley, Frank Meyer, and Ronald Reagan, was built around shared opposition to communism, shared support for free markets, and shared distrust of big government. That alliance held reasonably well through the 1980s but has strained since the end of the Cold War. The libertarian-conservative split on foreign policy after 9/11, the civil liberties debates around the Patriot Act, the rise of national conservatism under Donald Trump, and disputes about free trade have all exposed deeper philosophical differences that were masked during the Cold War. The alliance still exists, but it is less stable than it once was.
Are You Libertarian or Conservative?
Find out in less than 5 minutes by taking the World's Smallest Political Quiz.