Who Owns Your Safety When a Dangerous Neighbor Lurks?

Law, Order, and the Tao of Defending Yourself

Who Owns Your Safety When a Dangerous Neighbor Lurks?

AI-generated image

A number of years ago, while walking past the front door of the condo I shared with my girlfriend, I heard an altercation outside. I proceeded to look through the peephole and saw my neighbor arguing with someone he knew. Then, to my shock and amazement, he pulled out a knife and stabbed the man.

Law enforcement arrived well after the fact. When the officers finally got there, they handcuffed our neighbor, interviewed witnesses, then stood around talking for the better part of ninety minutes. Our neighbor’s door was shattered from the struggle, glass and blood covered the stair landing we shared with him. No one in the community knew what would happen next.

That experience taught me something no civics class could: Government promises protection, but what happens in real life can be very different. We can encounter that reality in our daily lives: at home with an abusive spouse, at a nightclub at 2 a.m., or walking to your car in a dark parking garage.

So I'll ask the question plainly, to you, a self-governing reader: who owns your safety?

An Adjacent Neighbor Who Poses Danger

My partner and I parted ways about ten years ago, but we still love and care about one another, and we talk often. She still resides at the same address, a condo she’s called home for over twenty-five years.

Unfortunately, issues with her neighbor continue to escalate in the community as we speak, even though his unit is boarded up and now uninhabitable.

To protect those in this story that's still unfolding, I'll call my former partner Anya and the neighbor Rob.

Rob is a felon who has spent years menacing the complex. He has angry outbursts at neighbors, damages property, and leaves junk strewn across the property.

He lurks in the parking lot, sleeps in his car, watches people, and gets into confrontations with anyone in the neighborhood who dares to stand up to him. He was suspected of setting fire to his own unit, which shares a wall with my ex. The HOA rebuilt it pursuant to their guidelines, but state inspectors have deemed it uninhabitable. It is now boarded up.

Unfortunately, that unit opens onto the same second-floor landing as Anya's front door. Rob breaks in regularly, turns on the water, and regularly floods the condo below through the flooring.

It’s hard not to see patterns of serious, untreated mental illness as a major contributing factor behind the behavior. Rob’s name is on the deed to the property, which is owned by a relative who is now fighting to get him removed so she can sell it. The HOA is entangled legally, with some residents believing it carries some accountability. This is particularly true given the danger Rob continues to pose to the community as long as he remains on the deed.

Despite repeated calls, law enforcement has done little or nothing. Anya wants to leave, but the same criminal activity that frightens her has drained her property's value. She is trapped twice: by fear and by an asset the chaos has gutted.

The neighbors are at a crossroads. Some are gun owners who talk about banding together. Others are pursuing legal remedies. Some want private security. They are discovering a lesson that I continue to ponder: the state-supported cavalry isn't coming to protect them or address this menace. That is until it’s too late and something very serious happens.

The Promise with No Guarantee

Most Americans assume that government has a legal duty to protect. Technically, they do not.

In Town of Castle Rock v. Gonzales (2005), Jessica Gonzales held a restraining order against her estranged husband. He took their three daughters against their will. She called the police again and again throughout the night. The police didn't enforce the order, and he murdered the girls.

The U.S. Supreme Court ruled 7 to 2 that she had no constitutional entitlement to police enforcement of that order. The court was informed in that decision by DeShaney v. Winnebago County (1989), which held that the state generally has no constitutional duty to protect individuals from private violence.

In short, the state claims a monopoly on legitimate force, disarms or discourages citizens, and then asserts in court that it doesn’t actually owe them any protection. Oh, and it forces us to pay for it all, through our taxes.

Life, liberty, and property do not exist because men have made laws. On the contrary, it was the fact that life, liberty, and property existed beforehand that caused men to make laws in the first place.

— Frédéric Bastiat, The Law (1850)

Bastiat reverses the usual story. Law doesn't create our right to exist safely; it was supposed to serve a right we already had. When the law stops serving, the right doesn't vanish. It comes home to the individual who owned it all along.

What the Old Masters Knew

As a Taoist, I keep going back to Lao Tzu, who distrusted the noisy machinery of command.

In Chapter 57 of the Tao Te Ching he warns that the more laws and orders are displayed, the more thieves and robbers there will be.

Then there’s Chapter 17, where he says the best rulers are those the people barely know exist. When the work is done, the people say, “We did it ourselves.”

That’s the self-governing ideal in four words: we did it ourselves.

Yet Lao Tzu was no romantic about force. In Chapter 31, he calls weapons instruments of ill omen. The wise person uses them only when there's no other choice, takes no joy in victory, and treats even a just fight as an occasion for mourning.

Confucius comes at it from the other side. In Analects 2.3, he observes that if you lead people by laws and keep them in line with punishments, they will try to avoid the punishment but feel no shame. Lead them by virtue and ritual propriety, and they develop a sense of shame and set themselves right.

Then comes the passage every gun-rights debate should study. Paraphrasing Analects 12.7, Confucius’ disciple Zigong asks what good government requires. Confucius answers: enough food, enough weapons, and the trust of the people. If one must go, Zigong asks, which? Weapons first, Confucius says. And if another must go? Food. But without trust, he says, no community can stand.

To see what is right and not to do it is want of courage.

—Confucius, Analects 2.24

Hold these two masters together, and the tension sharpens. Lao Tzu warns that more law breeds more disorder. Confucius warns that arms without trust are worthless. Both are speaking to Anya's neighborhood.

The Rifle and the Phone Call

Let me stage the argument as it actually happens in Anya's complex.

Some of the other neighbors say: We called. We filed reports. We waited. Nothing. The Second Amendment isn't a suggestion. The Supreme Court affirmed an individual right to bear arms in District of Columbia v. Heller (2008). If the state won't protect us, we will protect ourselves. A man who stabs people doesn't get to set the terms of our lives.

The patient citizen says: Let law enforcement and the courts handle it. Armed neighbors confronting a mentally ill man is how a nuisance becomes a funeral. If someone fires a weapon on that landing, the person in prison might not be Rob.

To the patient citizen: waiting is not neutral. Waiting is a choice to keep outsourcing your life to an institution that has told you, in writing, that it owes you nothing. “Let law enforcement handle it” turns into “let no one handle it” when law enforcement doesn't show up.

To the armed neighbor: a band of residents carrying rifles to ‘deal with' one troubled man isn't self-government. It's a mob on a mission. Self-defense is the right to stop an aggression in front of you. It isn't a license for collective punishment, and the gap between those two is where neighborhoods lose their souls.

The self-governing answer refuses both surrender and swagger. It says: I hold the right to defend myself, and I carry the burden of restraint that comes with it.

Buying Back the Night: Private Security and the Market for Protection

When Anya’s neighbors talk about hiring private security, they're rediscovering a radical idea that's 175 years old.

In 1849, the Belgian-French economist Gustave de Molinari published “The Production of Security.” He argued that protection is a service like any other, and that it would be supplied better and more cheaply by competing providers than by a coercive monopoly. It was heresy then. Today, private security guards are a common sight across America, guarding malls, campuses, and gated communities.

Murray Rothbard sharpened the point. In Anatomy of the State, he defined the state as the organization that tries to maintain a monopoly on the use of force and violence in a given territory. In For a New Liberty, he made the case that police services, like any others, could be provided through voluntary exchange. A security firm that ignores your calls loses its contract. A police department that ignores your calls loses nothing.

But Anya's story adds a hard lesson for market anarchists too. The HOA is a private governing body, and it rebuilt the unit of a man suspected of burning it. Private institutions fail as well.

The difference is accountability: a private body can be sued, voted out, defunded by its own members, and held liable. The answer isn't blind faith in markets over government. It's the insistence that whoever provides your safety must answer to you.

Anya's Line: Women, Boundaries, and Bodily Freedom

Picture Anya opening her front door, knowing that her neighbor Rob has made so many in the neighborhood, particularly women, feel uncomfortable.

For women, the abstract debate about “law and order” collapses into something intimate:

Can I walk to my car? 

What’s your political type?

Find out right now by taking The World’s Smallest Political Quiz.

Take the Political Quiz

Can I come home after dark? 

Can I say no and make it stick?

Bodily freedom isn't only about choices made in a doctor's office. It's the freedom to set a boundary and enforce it when someone refuses to honor it.

Each of us has a natural right, from God, to defend his person, his liberty, and his property.

—Frédéric Bastiat, The Law (1850)

A person’s right to defend themselves is the most concrete form of consent there is. Protection that only exists when a police officer happens to be nearby isn't under her purview of control. It belongs to the state, on loan, and as Jessica Gonzales learned, the loan can be called at the worst possible moment.

This is where law and order shows its real face. Does it protect a woman's agency, or does it ask her to give it up, call the number, wait, and hope? A system that disarms her, discourages her, and then disclaims responsibility for her hasn't given her order. It has handed her helplessness and called it good.

The Price of Freedom Should Not Be Fear

Here is the hardest question in this piece, and I won't pretend it's easy: can we reject a state monopoly on safety without making fear, force, or unequal power the price of freedom?

If self-defense depends on owning a handgun, paying for training, and living somewhere that tolerates it, then the right to safety belongs to the comfortable. The strong, the wealthy, and the confident get protection. The elderly widow, the single mother working two jobs, and the woman who has never held a weapon get anxiety.

So the self-governing response has to be broader than a gun. To me, it looks like:

Training as mutual aid: neighbors teaching neighbors situational awareness, de-escalation, and, for those who choose it, safe and lawful firearm handling.

Watchfulness without vigilantism: cameras, documentation, shared logs, and walking each other to cars after dark.

Collective legal pressure: pooling resources for attorneys to hold the HOA and the property owner.

Voluntary security: paying for private patrols as a cooperative, so protection doesn't depend on any one household's income.

Compassion with boundaries: pushing for real mental-health intervention for Rob, because a man in crisis is a human being as well as a hazard.

These responses embody the Taoist philosophical concept of wu wei as applied to the street: not passivity, but action that flows with the grain of things instead of against it. Strength held in reserve. Weapons as a very last resort, never a first instinct. And it is the Confucian insight made local: without trust, no community stands. Arms without trust are just more danger on the stair landing.

So, Who Owns Your Safety?

I still think about that night at the peephole. I've come to believe the most dangerous lie of law and order isn't that the police will protect. It's the quieter lie that your safety was never yours to begin with.

At the end of the day, it was always yours. Bastiat knew it. Molinari and Rothbard built a new conception of security and justice upon it. Lao Tzu warned that the more rules we stack up, the more disorder we invite. Confucius warned that weapons without trust are worthless.

Anya's neighborhood is learning what self-governing people eventually learn: protection isn't a product you're issued. It's a responsibility you take back, carefully, together, and without hatred.

The question isn't whether the state will save you. The courts have already answered that. The question is whether you'll accept your own sovereignty, and whether you'll take on the courage and the restraint that come with it.

We did it ourselves. That is the Tao of a free and safer neighborhood.

Share this article

Recommended Reading

Are You Trapped in Someone Else’s Ideological Script?
The Tao of Liberty

Are You Trapped in Someone Else’s Ideological Script?

Most of us absorb ideas about work, politics, family, and success long before we stop to examine them. Thinking for yourself begins with figuring out which of those ideas you actually believe.

13 min read

Who Needs Permission to Heal You?
The Tao of Liberty

Who Needs Permission to Heal You?

Who controls your medical care? A former hospital administrator examines free-market healthcare—and the institutions standing between patient and doctor.

9 min read

The Kitchen With No Kings
The Tao of Liberty

The Kitchen With No Kings

Bourdain saw what polished institutions often miss: people usually know how to make things work when they’re trusted to get on with it.

8 min read